Oregon Historic Sites Database

Search Menu

Site Information small logo

Oregon Historic Sites Database

address: FS 3113 Rd historic name:Summit Creek Guard Station
Unincorporated, Umatilla County current/other names:
assoc addresses:
block/lot/tax lot:
location descr: twnshp/rng/sect/qtr sect:1S3 7E 17
resource type:Building height (stories):1.0 total elig resources:2 total inelig resources:1
elig evaluation: eligible/contributing NR Status:
prim constr date:c.1933 second date: date indiv listed:
primary orig use: Forest orig use comments:
second orig use:
primary style: Rustic prim style comments:
secondary style: sec style comments:
primary siding: Shingle siding comments:metal roof
secondary siding: Wood:Other/Undefined
plan type: Other Residential Type architect:
builder:CCC
comments/notes:
Umatilla National Forest Identification Number 06140600835
Survey/Grouping Included In: Type of Grouping Date Listed Date Compiled
   Umatilla National Forest National Forest
NR date listed: N/A
ILS survey date: 07/22/2010
RLS survey date:
106 Project(s)
SHPO Case Date Agency Effect Eval
10-2209 09/20/2010 no adverse effect
Special Assess Project(s): None
Federal Tax Project(s): None
(Includes expanded description of the building/property, setting, significant landscape features, outbuildings and alterations)
Legal -- NE ¼ of the NE ¼ of the SW ¼ of Section 17, Township 01 South, Range 37 East, Willamette Meridian; UTM Datum NAD83, Zone 11 T, 0405884m East 5036558m North USGS Map Drumhill Ridge, Oregon 1964(1983) Access: From Interstate Highway 84, Exit 243, travel east on Forest Service Road 31 (aka Mt. Emily Road., aka Summit Road) for approximately 13.0 miles to Forest Service Road 3113 and turn northwest onto FS 3113. Continue northwest for approximately 1.0 mile. The Summit Guard Station Complex is located west of the road and the datum is located near the center of the complex. Setting: The site is located along the flat narrow crest of Drumhill Ridge overlooking East Meacham Creek to the southwest. The guard station is surrounded by patchy mixed conifer forest and subalpine meadows. The ridge is the erosional remnant of a broad basalt plateau that has been dissected by numerous tributaries of the Umatilla River. Basalt bedrock is exposed in places. The site includes a two-story guard house residence (Umatilla NF Building No. 1023), a one-story residential structure (Umatilla NF Building No. 1305), a standing outbuilding (Umatilla NF Building No. 2405), and a collapsed outbuilding (Umatilla NF Building No. 1511). The one-story residence has previously been deemed not eligible for the National Register of Historic Places and is not included in this evaluation. The site also includes a flag pole, split-rail fence, and dirt driveways. The complex is still in use by the Umatilla National Forest and was in use as housing for a crew of wild land firefighters during the evaluation. Summit Guard House (Building 1023): The summit Guard House (constructed in 1933) is located within the Umatilla National Forest. The structure lies on a raised concrete/stone foundation, and is a one and a half story side-gabled, platform (western) frame that measures 24’ x 30’. The style in not remarkable (Folk National and very similar to the Cape Cod or Colonial Revival style popular in the 1930s), and was constructed for purely utilitarian functions. The roof mass is steeply pitched and clad with raised seam metal panels; the central chimney explodes just off-center of the roof ridge to roughly 36” above the roofline; soffits are closed and eaves extend ever so slightly. There are two wall dormers; the rear elevation dormer features a shed roof style, the front façade dormer is gabled like the main roof mass and projects ca. 36” from the eaves to the ground level; the lower portion of this dormer also caps the enclosed front porch/entryway. Exterior walls are clad with wood shingles (shakes), then, directly above the half-story level, vertical wood weatherboarding is used within the gables. All windows appear to be original 6-over-1 double hung sash, with the exception of the pantry area to the rear of the kitchen,(which are solid pane), and the dormer windows that are also solid pane with decorative mutins; (the window in the rear dormer sheds light on the stairwell in the half-story area, while the window in the front dormer merely sheds light into the attic). The interior of the house has retained much of its original integrity, although modifications have been made; linoleum in the kitchen, hall, dining room area, and bath, and 4’ x 8’ x 1/8 inch wall paneling, popular in the late 1960s through mid-1970s, in the dining room and living room. All window and door hardware is original; all interior doors are original wood, five panel-styled doors throughout. Original hardwood flooring is in the ground floor bedroom and all rooms on the half-story level, including the stairs. Interior walls, with the exception of the dining room and living room, are clad with wallboard/sheet rock; there seems to be no evidence of lath and plaster. Summit Guard House Warehouse (Building 2405): The Summit warehouse is nearly square in configuration and measures 30’ x 24’. The roof has a moderate to steep pitch and is clad with wood shingles; rafter tails “punch” through the drop siding just below the open eaves, that overhang ever so slightly; the structure rests entirely on a raised, concrete foundation. There are a total of eight windows, three individual banks at the gabled elevations, and two each on the longitudinal sides that are positioned at each side of the full, batten, sliding wood doors; the glass panes are broken up into six panes with a decorative muntin/mullion configuration. Summit Guard House Garage (Building 1511): This structure was recently destroyed by heavy snow load (90% destroyed). The roof has fallen into the structure and the walls have been pressed outward. The structure is unstable and lacks integrity.
(Chronological, descriptive history of the property from its construction through at least the historic period - preferably to the present)
Significance: Established in 1905, the National Forest Service (NFS) emerged from humble beginnings. From the start of the early twentieth century until approximately 1920, the responsibility of housing of NFS personnel was, more often than not, undertaken by the employees themselves. Primitive log structures were common, or use of any construction material that was cheap enough and obtainable at the time; in this respect, the vernacular structure within the NFS was at its most basic. (Grosvenor 1999:3) Architectural style throughout the Service developed slowly, but soon became a priority among Forest Service administrators. By 1936, the Service went through unprecedented administrative expansion and the creation of the Architectural Division was part of that expansion. Administrative buildings, guard houses, barns, etc., were foremost on the list for obvious reasons, but later came the advent of the recreational structure, a phenomena that both rose and fell during the Depression era. That being said, it would be the era of the Great Depression (1933-1941), and subsequent New Deal legislation ushered in by then-president Franklin D. Roosevelt that would spawn numerous back-to-work programs, including arguably one of the most successful; the Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC). Activities of the CCC in the Pacific Northwest forests consisted of trail and road building/maintenance, repair of telephone lines, construction of guard houses, barns, corrals, campgrounds, and community kitchens. Steen gives an excellent account of the average CCC enrollee during the 1930s: “Statistically the average CCC enrollee was twenty years old and from a family of six. He had an eighth grade-grade education and had been unemployed for at least nine months, as had his father. After passing rigorous military tests for heath and discipline, the enrollee was assigned to one of several thousand work camps. There he lived in wooden barracks, working and playing hard. Good food, laboring out of doors on conservation projects, and relaxation were part of the typical day. Self improvement was an important duty…all of this and thirty dollars a month, most of which was obligated to dependents.” (Steen; 215 2004) The Summit Guard guardhouse, constructed in 1933, was a relatively new feature at the time it was constructed, within the Forest Service, and buildings such as this would eventually replace the long-standing fire lookout towers. Eligibility: The Summit Guard Station, along with contributing structure(s), with the exception of the garage, is eligible for inclusion on the National Register of Historic Places under Criteria A (the property is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history). The Guard House (Building 1023) and Warehouse (Building 2405) have been maintained and the utilities updated since they were constructed but overall retain the look, feel, and character of the guard station complex. The Garage (Building 1511) has been damaged to such a degree that it lacks integrity and cannot be simply repaired. The organization of the grounds overall reflects the original structure of the guard station complex.
Title Records Census Records Property Tax Records Local Histories
Sanborn Maps Biographical Sources SHPO Files Interviews
Obituaries Newspapers State Archives Historic Photographs
City Directories Building Permits State Library
Local Library: University Library:
Historical Society: Other Respository:
Bibliography:
Grosvenor, John R. 1999 A History of the Architecture of the USDA Forest Service, USDA, Forest Service, Engineering Staff, Washington, D.C. Steen, Harold K. 2004 The U.S. Forest Service: A History, Forest History Society in cooperation with University of Washington Press. Seattle, WA.