STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE
SUMMARY
Located in Lane County, Eugene Civic Stadium is the only known example of a Depression Era ballpark left in the state of Oregon. Eugene Civic Stadium was built in 1938 on the east side of Willamette Street in Eugene, between 20th and 22nd Avenues. Built as a cooperative between the Eugene Chamber of Commerce, Eugene Public School District No. 4, and the Works Progress Administration (WPA), Civic Stadium is significant to the development of the nation’s favorite pastime, and is one of the oldest extant ballparks in the United States.
Continuously used as a municipal athletic facility since its inception, Eugene Civic Stadium meets National Register Criterion A for its initial and continued contribution to the entertainment and recreational needs of Eugene and the surrounding communities in the Pacific Northwest. The stadium also meets Criterion A for its distinctive characteristics of community planning and development, which brought the government and community together during the Depression Era. Eugene Civic Stadium is also eligible for listing in the National Register under Criterion C for its architecture, being typical of Depression Era stadiums constructed throughout the Pacific Northwest. Civic Stadium bears a marked resemblance to the Grandstand design illustrated by the Timber Engineering Company in the book Typical Designs of Timber Structures: A Reference for Use by Architects and Engineers under the heading of “Typical Design No. 109: Grandstand.” Eugene Civic Stadium retains excellent integrity of design, setting, materials, workmanship, location, feeling and association. The period of significance begins with its initial construction date of 1938 and ends in 1939 when the roof was constructed.
THE WPA AND EUGENE CIVIC STADIUM
The 4J Public School District has been the sole proprietor of Eugene Civic Stadium since its construction in 1938. The land where Civic Stadium is located, known as the Amazon tract, was deeded to the school district in 1938 with the understanding that the property was “to be used as a recreation area for School District and for the municipality.” Area businesses provided many of the necessary materials, and a regional campaign spearheaded by the Eugene City School District and the local community raised additional money for the stadium, enabling the project to break ground in 1938. The labor for the construction of the stadium was donated by the Works Project Administration (WPA).
The Great Depression of the 1930s resulted in massive unemployment throughout the country. Initiated by President F.D. Roosevelt as a relief measure to combat the effects of the Depression, the WPA provided jobs to accomplished laborers yielding public projects that utilized the skills of the nation by 1935. The program was designed to provide work for the unemployed and to aid in subsidizing costs associated with new construction or repairs of public works projects. Essentially, the federal program enabled large scale projects on small scale budgets, donating time and labor to communities across the country for nearly a decade. By the time the program was disbanded in June 1943, it had employed over 8.5 million people and completed well over one million projects.
In Lane County, Oregon, the WPA completed numerous public improvement projects, including distributing hot lunches to needy children, improving roads and sanitation systems, and rebinding books. In 1935, the WPA made major repairs to Eugene City Hall. In 1936, the WPA was involved in landscaping portions of the University of Oregon campus and making improvements to Skinner Butte and Hendricks Parks.
Nearly all of the WPA building projects in Lane County were done in coordination with the schools, including high school gymnasiums for School Districts #12 and #133 in 1938, an addition to the Architecture and Allied Arts Building at the University of Oregon in 1939, and a music building for School District 4J in 1940. By far the largest civic improvement project completed by the WPA in Lane County, however, was Civic Stadium, with a total of over $37,000 appropriated for the project in 1938.
By 1937 there was a growing need for an athletic field in Eugene, both for the community and schools. On December 3, 1937, the Eugene Register-Guard printed the first article referencing the “Big Amazon Park Project.” By December 8, 1937, a committee had been formed by the Eugene Chamber of Commerce and plans were being formulated for a new athletic field to be built through the cooperation of the Chamber Committee, the Eugene Public School Board, and the Eugene City Council. By December 24, 1937, the WPA was reported to be interested in the development and building of the recreation center.
On January 11, 1938, the Register-Guard presented the facts regarding the financial plans for the new athletic field. The city council was asked to turn over the land known as the Amazon tract, which was held for $6,000 in back taxes. The school board was asked to contribute $6,000, and the committee guaranteed to raise another $6,000 so the first year work could be completed. The WPA was set to contribute the labor. The $12,000 contributed by the school board and the committee would be enough to grade the field and build the covered grandstand, which would seat 4,000 people.
On January 26, 1938, the Register-Guard reported the “Park Project is Threatened by Deadlock.” The concern of who would pay the $6,000 in back tax assessments, the city or the school board, seemed to spell the end of the project. Without the deed from the city, the school board was concerned that they would not be able to secure the WPA for the project. The controversy lasted months, until it was decided to put the vote to the community.
On Friday, May 20, 1938, Eugene citizens went to the polls to vote on the issue to levy a one-half mill tax to repay the debt of $6,000 in outstanding liens to the property. Voters approved the project by an almost 2-1 margin, enabling the proposed athletic field to move forward. The title to the Amazon tract was deeded over to Eugene Public School District 4J on June 13, 1938 to “be used as a recreation area for the School District and for the municipality.”
Eugene Civic Stadium would never have been constructed without the display of outstanding public support it received and the cooperation of the numerous civic agencies involved. This unique cohesion of community development and city planning illustrates the camaraderie apparent in WPA projects built throughout the country during the Depression Era. Essentially, the stadium helped bring both the government and community together during these difficult times.
On May 15, 1938, just prior to the special election, the Eugene Register-Guard presented a plan to the public for the proposed development of the Amazon tract area. The proposed site would include a football and baseball field and grandstand, track field, swimming pool, tennis courts, shuffle board and Ping-Pong courts. The plan was to begin on the football and baseball field first, with the other areas being developed later.
Work began on June 21, 1938, with Jay F. Oldham contracted to grade the land. Graham Smith, a local of Eugene, was named architect for the grandstand, the plans of which were approved in July. Smith, along with the manpower of the WPA, utilized local old growth Douglas fir exclusively in the construction of the grandstand. The work was completed in mid-September, and a dedication ceremony featuring the Eugene High School marching band was held on October 22, 1938.
The first event at Civic Stadium, the annual rivalry football match between Eugene High and Corvallis High, was held on October 28, 1938. The grandstand still did not have a roof, and both players and fans were rain-soaked by the end of the game. The match, played on the clay and sawdust field, ended in a 0-0 tie.
By the 1939 football season, floodlights and the grandstand roof had been erected at Civic Stadium. The roof was designed by the West Coast Lumberman’s Association of Seattle, Washington, and utilizes the same local, old growth Douglas fir that can be found in the grandstand construction. Plans for the other parts of the athletic complex never materialized and the land was developed into South Eugene High School.
Eugene Civic Stadium was primarily home to high school football, baseball and soccer games between 1938 and 1969. The stadium was designed as a multi-use facility, and converted easily for various types of sporting events. Eugene Civic Stadium has been home to numerous high school ball games, graduations, 4th of July celebrations and even rodeos throughout the years, and continues to serve as a multi-purpose facility hosting baseball and soccer events.
In 1941 a heating plant, a small ancillary building with an 880 gallon water tank, was added to the site, which initially acted as the sole source for hot water at the stadium, and serviced the locker and bath rooms by utilizing sawdust to run the boiler. Another building followed in 1946 that served as a repair garage for the school district’s bus depot and living quarters. With the stadium operating both Saturday night and Sunday afternoon for hardball games and at least twice a week for softball, the groundskeeper was on duty 24 hours. Recognizing that this was a full time job, the school district built two apartments above the garage, one for the groundskeeper and his family and the other likely for bus drivers or the manager for the bus barn. Other permanent and temporary buildings, including ticket booths and concessions stands, have also been added to the site since the 1960s and 1970s.
In 1969, Civic Stadium became home to Eugene’s own minor league baseball team, the Emeralds. Upgraded to the Class AAA Pacific Coast League, the Eugene Emeralds required a larger facility than they currently had, and sought the assistance of the Eugene School District when plans to build a new stadium were unsuccessful. Baseball had not been played at Civic Stadium in over twenty years, but the team was granted a three-year lease to use and improve the stadium. Currently, the Eugene Emeralds are ranked as one of the most popular teams of the Northwest League, having drawn no less than 100,000 fans per year since 1985. As of opening day 2006, Eugene Civic Stadium was the 11th Oldest Minor League Ballpark in the United States, and was within the top ten by opening day 2007. It is the third oldest minor league stadium in use west of the Rocky Mountains. Civic Stadium is a place where a community enjoys America’s favorite pastime every summer, and is a part of Eugene’s living history.
SIGNIFICANCE AND INTEGRITY
Civic Stadium is nominated under National Register Criterion A for its initial and continued contribution to the entertainment and recreational needs of Eugene and for its distinctive characteristics of community planning, which brought the government and community together during the Depression Era. Since its original design plan was released to the public in 1938, Eugene Civic Stadium has been regarded as a signature athletic facility for municipal use. Owned continuously by the Eugene Public School District 4J, the initial function of the stadium as a municipal recreation facility is still observed today as host to the Eugene Emeralds, as well as various local and high school baseball and soccer teams.
The site was developed in conjunction with the WPA, the Chamber of Commerce, Eugene School District No. 4, and the public at large. This illustration of community camaraderie is representative of Depression Era projects built by the WPA in the United States in the late 1930s. This durable, useful structure constructed of local materials by local craftsmen with local funds illustrates the ability of multiple institutions to work together on a local level. The involvement of the WPA demonstrates how federal programs can work with individual communities to establish a public facility that has remained a continuous piece of America’s living history.
In addition, Eugene Civic Stadium is eligible for the National Register under Criterion C as being typical of stadiums built during the Depression Era in the Pacific Northwest. In 1930, the Timber Engineering Company published the book Typical Designs of Timber Structures: A Reference for Use by Architects and Engineers. Under the heading of “Typical Design No. 109: Grandstand” is illustrated a prototype for a municipal grandstand and its accompanying transverse hip truss roof. Both the roof and the grandstand are nearly identical in form and structure to Eugene Civic Stadium.
Stadiums like Eugene Civic Stadium were built in conjunction with local organizations, such as the West Coast Lumberman’s Association, throughout the Pacific Northwest. Unfortunately, these beautiful wooden grandstands have fallen victim to progress and neglect, and many have been demolished to make room for more modern facilities. Eugene Civic Stadium is the only wooden grandstand of this type remaining in Oregon, and one of only two known remaining in the Pacific Northwest (the other is Olympic Stadium, located in Hoquiam, Washington).
Overall, Eugene Civic Stadium retains excellent integrity of design, setting, materials, workmanship, location, feeling and association. While the neighborhood has undergone massive development over the last eighty years, the site once known as the Amazon tract is still surrounded by neighborhoods and is used as a municipal recreation facility. South Eugene High School, with its own athletic fields, has been constructed due west of Eugene Civic Stadium on a portion of the land initially laid out for the athletic facility. The rest of the land has been developed into Amazon Park, a city park featuring soccer and football fields, as well as jogging and biking trails and a dog park.
Eugene Civic Stadium also retains integrity of materials, workmanship, design, feeling, and association. Little has been done to alter the timber frame construction that exists under the grandstand. The old growth Douglas fir has needed little maintenance over the years and remains in excellent condition. The quality of construction is also tested every summer, when thousands of fans fill the seats, stomping and roaring to cheer on the Eugene Emeralds. Integrity of workmanship is also retained, specifically in regards to its unique method of construction utilizing local, old growth Douglas fir, local designers and architects, and local labor during construction. Additionally, the stadium has retained its designed use as a multi-purpose recreational facility, and is still utilized in its intended fashion as an athletic park hosting baseball, both local teams as well as the Eugene Emeralds, and soccer.
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Eugene Civic Stadium can be compared with three different categories of properties: 1) other stadiums in the Pacific Northwest; 2) other WPA-built stadiums in the United States; and 3) all other minor league ballparks in the United States.
Overall, Eugene Civic Stadium bears a marked resemblance to Olympic Stadium of Hoquiam, Washington, built in 1938. Olympic Stadium is roughly U-shaped and larger in size, with a seating capacity of around 10,000 people (Civic seats approximately 6,000 people in the grandstand). Olympic Stadium was listed in the National Register in 2006, features the same wooden post-on-pier construction, and was also constructed in conjunction with the WPA. Both parks are likely drawn from the same plates of the book Typical Designs for Timber Structures. Olympic Stadium retains its historic integrity, although the facility is not currently in use.
Another comparable property is National Register-listed Jay Littleton Park, located in Ontario, California. This facility is listed as the only known comparable property for Olympic Stadium in that stadium’s National Register nomination. Built between 1935 and 1937, the wooden grandstand is also roughly U-shaped and seats 3,500 fans. The facility was constructed for baseball only, and was the location for filming parts of the movie The Babe. Like Eugene Civic Stadium, Jay Littleton Park features an all-wooden grandstand.
PGE Park, located in Portland, Oregon, is another multi-purpose facility located in the Pacific Northwest. A recent $38.5 million renovation in 2000-2001 helped make PGE Park one of the finest stadiums in both the Pacific Coast Minor League Baseball League and the United Soccer League. PGE Park is home to the Portland Beavers AAA baseball team and the Portland Timbers, a member of the United Soccer Leagues First Division. PGE Park was originally built in 1926, but has undergone extensive alterations over the years, including the recent renovation which debuted to the public on April 30, 2001. Though the park advertises “Old Time Feel, State of the Art Features,” the past and recent renovations have severely compromised the historical integrity of the structure.
The second basis for comparison is on a national scale, with other ballparks constructed in conjunction with the WPA. While dozens of stadiums were built in partnership with local organizations by the WPA during the Depression Era, analyzing them for the scope of this nomination is not feasible. A few notable examples include Ray Winder Field, constructed in Little Rock, Arkansas in 1932; Recreation Park, constructed in Montpelier, Vermont in 1940; and Phil Welch Stadium, constructed in St. Joseph, Missouri also in 1940. Historic integrity on these three parks has not been determined. In addition, none of them appear to be constructed in the same manner, with large scale timbers, as Eugene Civic Stadium.
The third basis for comparison is to look at other minor league ballparks in the United States, since Eugene Civic Stadium is currently hosting the Eugene Emeralds baseball team. As of opening day 2006, Eugene Civic Stadium was the 11th oldest minor league ballpark in the United States. However, with the Arkansas Travelers relocating to a new field, Civic Stadium was within the top ten oldest stadiums by opening day 2007.
CONCLUSION
Eugene Civic Stadium is significant on a local level as a continuously functioning municipal athletic facility built in conjunction with the WPA. Civic Stadium meets National Register Criterion A for its initial and continued contribution to the entertainment and recreational needs of Eugene and the surrounding communities. The stadium also meets Criterion A for its distinctive characteristics of community planning and development.
In addition, Eugene Civic Stadium meets National Register Criterion C for its architecture, which was typical of the designs of ballparks built in association with the Timber Engineering Company throughout the Pacific Northwest. The design known as “Typical Design No. 109: Grandstand” is now exceedingly rare. Eugene Civic Stadium is nearly perfectly intact and is one of only two known remaining stadiums of this type.
Eugene Civic Stadium has been continuously owned and operated by the Eugene Public School District 4J since the land was deeded from the city in 1938. It has continuously served as a multi-purpose athletic facility for the municipality, and is a part of the living history of both Eugene and the nation. The sight of the hand turned score board, the feel of the old wooden grandstand, and the smell of the grass of the field transport people back to a time when war and financial woes could be escaped from, if only for a moment, at the ballpark. |